Commodity Tax Advisory Case Studies

6 worked Commodity Tax Advisory case studies — the position a client typically comes to us with, what we do, and what it is worth. Each is an illustrative example built on the rules that apply to commodity tax advisory work, not a specific client's file.

Case Study 1 · Deadline rescue

$143,000 Late-Filing Penalty Cancelled On Relief Application — Late GST/HST Registrant, Brampton

Client: A seller who crossed the registration threshold before registering. Where: Brampton, Ontario. Engagement: 4 weeks, fixed fee.

Penalty cancelled$143,000
Relief applicationGranted
ReturnAccepted as filed

Case 1: the situation

A seller who crossed the registration threshold before registering in Brampton, Ontario had already missed one deadline and was about to miss a second. Behind it sat export sales zero-rated with no shipping documentation behind them. A penalty of $143,000 was accruing.

Case 1: what we did

We split the work into what had to happen before the deadline and what could follow it. Then we assembled the export documentation, restored zero-rating on the qualifying sales, and reduced the proposed assessment.

Case 1: the result

The outstanding return was accepted as filed, and the taxpayer relief application cancelled $143,000 of the penalty already assessed on the earlier year.

Case Study 2 · Planning that cut the bill

$26,000 Saved By Correcting What Prior Filings Had Missed — Digital Platform Seller, Hamilton

Client: A platform seller collecting tax at checkout. Where: Hamilton, Ontario. Engagement: 7 weeks, fixed fee.

Saving identified$26,000
RecurringYes
Positions documentedAll

Case 2: the situation

A platform seller collecting tax at checkout in Hamilton, Ontario asked for a second opinion on commodity tax advisory. That followed three years of rising tax. The review found a commercial property purchase closed on the assumption no tax applied because the vendor was not registered.

Case 2: what we did

We built the comparison first: current structure against two alternatives. Then we rebuilt the sales ledger by customer province and applied the correct place-of-supply rate to each stream. We filed corrected returns before the CRA opened a review.

Case 2: the result

First-year saving of $26,000, with the same benefit recurring. Every position taken is documented and supported in the file.

Case Study 3 · Missed incentive claimed

Incentive Review Recovered $116,000 Across 7 Open Years — Interprovincial Construction Supplier, Calgary

Client: A construction supplier selling into three provinces. Where: Calgary, Alberta. Engagement: 9 weeks, fixed fee.

Recovered$116,000
Open years claimed7
Ongoing trackingIn place

Case 3: the situation

An incentive review at a construction supplier selling into three provinces in Calgary, Alberta started from a simple question: what has never been claimed? The answer ran to 7 years. It was driven by management fees between two related registrants carrying tax that only ever went out and came back.

Case 3: what we did

We self-assessed the tax on the real property acquisition in the correct reporting period and claimed the offsetting input tax credit in the same return. We documented eligibility to the standard a reviewer would apply rather than the standard a claim form requires.

Case 3: the result

The credits produced $116,000 across the open years. The tracking now in place means the following year's claim is documented as the work happens rather than reconstructed afterwards.

Case Study 4 · Structure rebuilt

Holding Structure Added, $60,000 Saved Annually — Wholesale Food Distributor, Moncton

Client: A wholesale food distributor. Where: Moncton, New Brunswick. Engagement: 7 weeks, fixed fee.

Annual saving$60,000
ReorganisationTax-neutral
StructureMatches operations

Case 4: the situation

The structure at a wholesale food distributor in Moncton, New Brunswick needed fixing. The file was carrying a sales tax account filed annually while the CRA had moved the business to quarterly. Every option for fixing it ran through a reorganisation that had to be done without triggering tax.

Case 4: what we did

We worked with the client's lawyer. Together, we set a defensible input tax credit allocation between taxable and exempt supplies and documented the method for future filings. We also prepared the elections, resolutions and valuations the structure needed to stand up.

Case 4: the result

The structure now matches the business. Annual saving of $60,000, and the reorganisation itself was tax-neutral.

Case Study 5 · Records and systems rebuilt

19 Months Reconciled And $4,300 Of Input Tax Recovered — Used-Equipment Dealer, Regina

Client: A used-equipment dealer. Where: Regina, Saskatchewan. Engagement: 8 weeks, fixed fee.

Months reconciled19
Input tax recovered$4,300
Close time6 days

Case 5: the situation

Nothing reconciled at a used-equipment dealer in Regina, Saskatchewan. Every filing started with 19 months of cleanup. The file was carrying nil periods left unfiled, which held up the refund on the one period that mattered.

Case 5: what we did

We rebuilt from source rather than correcting on top of the existing file. We tested the quick method against the account’s actual input tax credit history and stayed on the regular method where the credits were worth more. Then we set the routine that keeps it clean.

Case 5: the result

19 months reconciled to the bank. The close now takes 6 days, and $4,300 of previously unclaimable input tax was recovered in the process.

Case Study 6 · Scaling without breaking

Second-Province Expansion Handled, $90,000 Of Cash Released — Freight Brokerage, Surrey

Client: A freight brokerage. Where: Surrey, British Columbia. Engagement: 6 weeks, fixed fee.

Cash released$90,000
New registrationsComplete on day one
Compliance gapsNone

Case 6: the situation

Revenue at a freight brokerage in Surrey, British Columbia was up sharply and cash was tighter than ever. Underneath it sat input tax credits claimed on the exempt side of a mixed-supply business.

Case 6: what we did

We filed the section 156 election for the related registrants, so supplies between them stopped carrying tax that served no purpose but cash-flow drag. Every new obligation was set up before it was triggered, not after. That covered registration, remittance frequency and provincial filing.

Case 6: the result

$90,000 of cash was released from the working capital cycle. The expansion completed with every registration and filing obligation covered from day one.

Reviewed by Udit Gupta, Director, Cross-Border Tax Expert, for the 2025 tax year. These case studies are illustrative worked examples composed from the CRA rules that apply to this type of work, not specific client files; figures are representative and outcomes depend on your own facts.

Sources. CRA — Businesses · Income Tax Act (Justice Laws Website)

← Back to Commodity Tax Advisory  ·  All case studies

Free 15 Min Consultation for Businesses

Ready to get started with Commodity Tax Advisory tax support?

Talk to a professional tax accountant about your situation. No obligation, and you only pay once the work is complete and you have approved it.

  • Tax accountant led team
  • Fixed fees, no hourly billing
  • Pay only after you approve

+1 (416) 619-0068 381 Front St W, Toronto, ON M5V 3R8

Our Partners Are Alumni of the World's Top Accounting and Tax Institutions

Chartered Professional Accountants Canada AICPA — American Institute of Certified Public Accountants Institute of Chartered Accountants of India Malaysian Institute of Accountants