T4 and T4A Amendment Case Studies

6 worked T4 and T4A Amendment case studies — the position a client typically comes to us with, what we do, and what it is worth. Each is an illustrative example built on the rules that apply to t4 and t4a amendment work, not a specific client's file.

Illustrative case study 1 · Scaling without breaking

Growth Handled Without A Missed Filing, $77,000 Freed — Home-Care Agency, Vancouver

Example client: A home-care agency. Where: Vancouver, British Columbia. Assumed engagement: 6 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Cash freed$77,000
Compliance failuresNone
ReportingMonthly

Case 1: the situation

A home-care agency in Vancouver, British Columbia was opening in a second province. That meant different filing obligations and a different payroll regime. Remittances still going out monthly after the business had moved to the accelerated threshold already sat in the file.

Case 1: how we would approach it

We moved the account to the correct remitter frequency and caught up the arrears. We filed a taxpayer relief request that cancelled the bulk of the penalty. We then put monthly reporting in place. That let the owner see the cash effect of growth while there was still time to act on it.

Case 1: the illustrative result

Growth was absorbed without a compliance failure. $77,000 of cash was released, and the monthly reporting now flags a problem while it is still small.

Illustrative case study 2 · Objection and relief

$135,000 Of Penalties And Interest Cancelled On Relief — Part-Time Program Employer, Kitchener

Example client: A charity with part-time program staff. Where: Kitchener, Ontario. Assumed engagement: 5 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Penalties and interest cancelled$135,000
Relief groundsAccepted
AssessmentAdjusted to filed position

Case 2: the situation

An assessment of $135,000 landed at a charity with part-time program staff in Kitchener, Ontario following a desk review. It turned on long-term contractors who met every test for employment. The auditor had not seen the records behind it.

Case 2: how we would approach it

We reconciled the payroll register, general ledger and T4 summary to the cent, then filed the amended slips. We then set out the legislative basis for the position alongside the documents supporting it.

Case 2: the illustrative result

$135,000 of penalties and interest was cancelled under the taxpayer relief provisions, and the underlying assessment was adjusted to match the filed position.

Illustrative case study 3 · CRA review defended

$93,000 Proposed Adjustment Withdrawn In Full — Contractor-Paid Clinic, Edmonton

Example client: A clinic paying its associates as contractors. Where: Edmonton, Alberta. Assumed engagement: 8 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Adjustment withdrawn$93,000
File closed in8 weeks
Penalties assessedNone

Case 3: the situation

A clinic paying its associates as contractors in Edmonton, Alberta received a proposal letter opening a review of T4 and T4A amendment. The CRA had identified company vehicles used personally with no logbook and no taxable benefit reported. It proposed an adjustment of $93,000, with 30 days to respond.

Case 3: how we would approach it

We treated the response as an evidence exercise rather than an argument. We filed the outstanding slips and summary and requested relief on the per-slip penalty with the reasons documented in writing. We then indexed every supporting document against the specific line the auditor had questioned.

Case 3: the illustrative result

The proposed adjustment was withdrawn in full — all $93,000 of it. The file closed in 8 weeks with no change to the assessed amounts and no penalty.

Illustrative case study 4 · Deadline rescue

3-Week Turnaround Beat The Deadline And Saved $65,000 — Seasonal Landscaping Employer, Victoria

Example client: A landscaping company with seasonal staff. Where: Victoria, British Columbia. Assumed engagement: 3 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Late-filing penalty avoided$65,000
Filed with14 days to spare
Next yearPapers ready

Case 4: the situation

A landscaping company with seasonal staff in Victoria, British Columbia was weeks away from the deadline for T4 and T4A amendment. Behind that sat T4s that did not agree to the payroll register or the general ledger. The exposure if the date slipped was around $65,000.

Case 4: how we would approach it

We reviewed each contractor against the CRA’s control and integration tests and converted those who met the employment tests. We priced the transition before it was forced by a ruling. The filing went in complete rather than provisional, so there was no amended return to follow.

Case 4: the illustrative result

Filed with 14 days to spare. $65,000 in late-filing penalties avoided, and the working papers are ready for the following year.

Illustrative case study 5 · Missed incentive claimed

$47,000 In Credits Claimed That Prior Filings Had Missed — Two-Province Retail Chain, Winnipeg

Example client: A retail chain across two provinces. Where: Winnipeg, Manitoba. Assumed engagement: 7 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Credits claimed$47,000
Years adjusted4
Review outcomeNo adjustment

Case 5: the situation

A retail chain across two provinces in Winnipeg, Manitoba had been filing for 4 years. In that time, the incentives its activity qualified for were never claimed. Behind that sat remittances still going out monthly after the business had moved to the accelerated threshold.

Case 5: how we would approach it

We tested each activity against the eligibility criteria rather than the description on the invoice. Then we paid the accrued bonus inside the 180-day window and kept the deduction in the year it was accrued.

Case 5: the illustrative result

$47,000 in credits claimed, with the open prior years adjusted as well. The claim passed review without adjustment.

Illustrative case study 6 · Records and systems rebuilt

Month-End Close Cut From 6 Weeks To 9 Days — High-Turnover Restaurant, Moncton

Example client: A restaurant with heavy seasonal turnover. Where: Moncton, New Brunswick. Assumed engagement: 8 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Close time before6 weeks
Close time after9 days
Year-endReview, not rebuild

Case 6: the situation

The accounting file at a restaurant with heavy seasonal turnover in Moncton, New Brunswick had a weak foundation. It was built on a bonus accrued to bring the year-end tax bill down and still unpaid more than a year later. The year-end had taken 6 weeks each of the last three years.

Case 6: how we would approach it

We wrote each pay code against its income tax, CPP and EI treatment. That way, a new benefit could not reach the payroll without a decision on how it was withheld. We also moved the reconciliations into the monthly cycle, so the year-end stopped being a rebuild.

Case 6: the illustrative result

The file reconciles. Month-end closes in 9 days instead of 6 weeks, and the year-end is a review rather than a reconstruction.

Reviewed by Udit Gupta, Director, Cross-Border Tax Expert, for the 2025 tax year. These case studies are illustrative worked examples composed from the CRA rules that apply to this type of work, not specific client files; figures are representative and outcomes depend on your own facts.

Sources. CRA — Payroll · CRA — Keeping records · Income Tax Act (Justice Laws Website)

← Back to T4 and T4A Amendment  ·  All case studies

Free 15 Min Consultation for Businesses

Ready to get started with T4 and T4A Amendment tax support?

Talk to a professional tax accountant about your situation. No obligation, and you only pay once the work is complete and you have approved it.

  • Tax accountant led team
  • Fixed fees, no hourly billing
  • Pay only after you approve

+1 (416) 619-0068 381 Front St W, Toronto, ON M5V 3R8

Our Partners Are Alumni of the World's Top Accounting and Tax Institutions

Chartered Professional Accountants Canada AICPA — American Institute of Certified Public Accountants Institute of Chartered Accountants of India Malaysian Institute of Accountants