Cross-Border Retirement Planning Case Studies

6 worked Cross-Border Retirement Planning case studies — the position a client typically comes to us with, what we do, and what it is worth. Each is an illustrative example built on the rules that apply to cross-border retirement planning work, not a specific client's file.

Illustrative case study 1 · Missed incentive claimed

Incentive Review Recovered $25,500 Across 7 Open Years — US Retirement Account Holder, Mississauga

Example client: A dual citizen with a US retirement account. Where: Mississauga, Ontario. Assumed engagement: 11 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Recovered$25,500
Open years claimed7
Ongoing trackingIn place

Case 1: the situation

An incentive review at a dual citizen with a US retirement account in Mississauga, Ontario started from a simple question: what has never been claimed? The answer ran to 7 years. It was driven by invoices paid to a non-resident consultant working on site in Canada with no Regulation 105 withholding taken.

Case 1: how we would approach it

We restructured the US holding so the Canadian and US characterisations aligned, ending the double taxation going forward. We documented eligibility to the standard a reviewer would apply rather than the standard a claim form requires.

Case 1: the illustrative result

The credits produced $25,500 across the open years. The tracking now in place means the following year's claim is documented as the work happens rather than reconstructed afterwards.

Illustrative case study 2 · Objection and relief

Notice Of Objection Allowed In Full, $93,000 Reversed — Arizona Snowbird, Windsor

Example client: A snowbird spending winters in Arizona. Where: Windsor, Ontario. Assumed engagement: 4 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Amount reversed$93,000
ObjectionAllowed in full
Account balanceNil

Case 2: the situation

A snowbird spending winters in Arizona in Windsor, Ontario had been reassessed for $93,000. 7 days were left on the objection deadline. The reassessment rested on invoices paid to a non-resident consultant working on site in Canada with no Regulation 105 withholding taken.

Case 2: how we would approach it

We filed the objection inside the deadline with a complete submission rather than a placeholder. Alongside it, we aligned the Canadian and US reporting of the same income so the foreign tax credit claim carried support on both returns.

Case 2: the illustrative result

The appeals officer allowed the objection in full. $93,000 was reversed and the account returned to a nil balance.

Illustrative case study 3 · Structure rebuilt

Reorganisation Completed Tax-Deferred, $24,000 Saved Each Year — US Citizen in Canada, Halifax

Example client: A US citizen living in Canada. Where: Halifax, Nova Scotia. Assumed engagement: 11 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Annual saving$24,000
Tax on reorganisationDeferred
Elections filedOn time

Case 3: the situation

A US citizen living in Canada in Halifax, Nova Scotia had outgrown the structure it started with. 25% withholding on gross Canadian rent where a section 216 election would have taxed only the net was the immediate problem. The longer-term one was that the structure blocked the next step.

Case 3: how we would approach it

We mapped the current structure and modelled the target. Then we applied the treaty rate to the dividend withholding, filed the NR4 return, and remitted the shortfall before the CRA assessed the payer for it. The tax-deferred elections were filed on time and the supporting valuations documented.

Case 3: the illustrative result

The reorganisation completed without triggering tax, and the new structure saves approximately $24,000 a year while removing the exposure the old one carried.

Illustrative case study 4 · Cash and remittance control

Remittance Schedule Corrected, $73,000 Refunded — US Pension Recipient, Toronto

Example client: A Canadian resident receiving US pension income. Where: Toronto, Ontario. Assumed engagement: 11 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Overpayment refunded$73,000
Late remittances sinceZero
ScheduleAutomated

Case 4: the situation

Remittances at a Canadian resident receiving US pension income in Toronto, Ontario were consistently late by a few days. That was enough to trigger penalties every quarter. Behind it sat dividends paid to a non-resident shareholder with nothing withheld, leaving the payer holding the liability.

Case 4: how we would approach it

We reported the deemed disposition properly on the departure return and claimed the foreign tax credits that had been left unused. Then we moved the remittance dates into a scheduled process rather than a monthly decision.

Case 4: the illustrative result

Penalties stopped from the following remittance onwards, and $73,000 of overpaid instalments was refunded.

Illustrative case study 5 · Records and systems rebuilt

Books Rebuilt From Source, $19,500 In Unclaimed Input Tax Found — Cross-Border Contractor, Kitchener

Example client: A contractor working on both sides of the border. Where: Kitchener, Ontario. Assumed engagement: 10 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Unclaimed tax found$19,500
Records rebuilt13 months
ProcessDocumented

Case 5: the situation

A contractor working on both sides of the border in Kitchener, Ontario could not answer basic questions about its own numbers. A departure year filed as a normal resident return with no deemed disposition reported sat between the bank statements and the ledger.

Case 5: how we would approach it

We filed the section 216 election with the supporting rental statements and recovered the excess withholding as a refund. We then documented the process so the work does not depend on any one person remembering how it was done.

Case 5: the illustrative result

Records rebuilt and reconciled, $19,500 recovered in input tax credits that the old file could not support, and a documented monthly process now in place.

Illustrative case study 6 · CRA review defended

$134,000 Proposed Adjustment Withdrawn In Full — US LLC Shareholder, Winnipeg

Example client: A shareholder of a US LLC. Where: Winnipeg, Manitoba. Assumed engagement: 5 weeks, fixed fee.

This is a worked example, not a client file. The client type, place and every figure are assumed to show how the rule works; your own result depends on your facts.

Adjustment withdrawn$134,000
File closed in5 weeks
Penalties assessedNone

Case 6: the situation

A shareholder of a US LLC in Winnipeg, Manitoba received a proposal letter opening a review of cross-border retirement planning. The CRA had identified winters spent in the United States with the day count kept casually and no residency position documented anywhere. It proposed an adjustment of $134,000, with 30 days to respond.

Case 6: how we would approach it

We treated the response as an evidence exercise rather than an argument. We filed the outstanding T1135 disclosures through the Voluntary Disclosures Program, which eliminated the penalty exposure entirely. We then indexed every supporting document against the specific line the auditor had questioned.

Case 6: the illustrative result

The proposed adjustment was withdrawn in full — all $134,000 of it. The file closed in 5 weeks with no change to the assessed amounts and no penalty.

Reviewed by Udit Gupta, Director, Cross-Border Tax Expert, for the 2025 tax year. These case studies are illustrative worked examples composed from the CRA rules that apply to this type of work, not specific client files; figures are representative and outcomes depend on your own facts.

Sources. CRA — International and non-resident taxes · Income Tax Act (Justice Laws Website)

← Back to Cross-Border Retirement Planning  ·  All case studies

Free 15 Min Consultation for Businesses

Ready to get started with Cross-Border Retirement Planning tax support?

Talk to a professional tax accountant about your situation. No obligation, and you only pay once the work is complete and you have approved it.

  • Tax accountant led team
  • Fixed fees, no hourly billing
  • Pay only after you approve

+1 (416) 619-0068 381 Front St W, Toronto, ON M5V 3R8

Our Partners Are Alumni of the World's Top Accounting and Tax Institutions

Chartered Professional Accountants Canada AICPA — American Institute of Certified Public Accountants Institute of Chartered Accountants of India Malaysian Institute of Accountants